No machine · No electricity · Just time

The Toddy Cold Brew System, reviewed honestly

One filter, ten minutes of prep, and twenty-four hours of patience — for coffee concentrate that keeps in your fridge for two weeks. We break down whether it’s worth it, and how it compares to the alternatives.

★★★★★ 4.74,153 Amazon ratings
$44.95Current price
2 qtPer batch

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Toddy Cold Brew System on a kitchen counter with a glass of iced coffee
12–24 hr slow immersion steep
Spec-based reviewsBuilt on manufacturer data & verified buyer reviews
Updated for 2026Prices and specs checked regularly
Honest tradeoffsWe say who a product isn’t for, too
One niche, done wellCold brew immersion brewing — nothing else
Explore

Find what you’re brewing for

Start here

Our most-read guides

All reviews →
Full Review

Toddy Cold Brew System Review

★★★★★4.7 · 4,153 ratings

What stands out, what doesn’t, and who it’s actually for.

Read the review →
Comparison

Toddy vs. OXO

★★★★★Both 4.5+ rated

Bigger batch and a cleaner cup, or a built-in spigot and no filters to buy?

Compare →
Comparison

Toddy vs. Takeya

★★★★★Budget vs. yield

Half the price, half the yield — is Takeya the smarter buy for smaller households?

Compare →
At a glance

Toddy vs. the alternatives

Full comparisons →
MakerMethodYieldSteep timePrice
Toddy Cold Brew SystemTop pickImmersion2 qt12–24 hr$44.95Review →
OXO Cold Brew Coffee MakerImmersion32 oz12–24 hr$49.95Compare →
Takeya Cold Brew MakerSteep & strain1 qt12–18 hr$19.99Compare →
Toddy Cold Brew System studio product shot
Why trust this site

We’re upfront about how this works

  • Every review is built on manufacturer specs and verified buyer data, cross-checked across sources
  • We say plainly who a product is not a good fit for, not just who it’s great for
  • This site earns a commission on qualifying Amazon purchases — it never changes what we recommend
  • Prices and specs are checked regularly and updated when they change
Read our full approach →
Guides

Latest recipes & care guides

Process

How Toddy cold brew actually works

1
Coarse grindLike sea salt, not sand
2
1:4 ratioCoffee to cold water, by weight
3
Steep 12–24 hrRoom temp, covered
4
Filter & drainThrough the felt filter
5
Dilute & enjoyRoughly 1:1 with water or milk
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is the Toddy cold brew maker worth it?

For regular cold brew drinkers, yes — see our full breakdown of when it does and doesn’t make sense.

How much caffeine is in cold brew coffee?

More per ounce than drip coffee before dilution. Full explanation here.

How long does cold brew concentrate last?

Up to two weeks refrigerated. More on storage.

Can I use a Toddy for tea?

Here’s what works and what doesn’t.